On several occasions in the past, I have written posts on November 1 or 2 about the Christian commemorations, All Saints Day and All Souls Day. So I will try not to repeat myself. But there are a few new factors this year. One of them is that, in addition to as ever remembering the hymn "For All the Saints" (with its, for me, highly problematical words), I suddenly also remembered a descant to the hymn, sung by the sopranos in my childhood Episcopal church choir. That such an obscure tune, possibly written by our organist and not in the hymnal, would survive in my head for nearly 60 years is remarkable.
The second factor was finding that I have a really negative response toward a term that is evidently used of saints in the Catholic church, "heroic virtue." At first glance, bravery (in the face of attack or death or challenges to one's faith) would not seem to be a bad thing -- especially when the saintly person is trying to help others. I guess the notion is that heroism comes easily to saints, and that it is second nature tor them to put others before themselves. No surprises there.
And yet...once you find yourself perched outside of the duality umbrella, this notion of sainthood can't help but rankle. It takes for granted conflict, two sides set up in opposition to one another, people being forced to fight (for their own faith or others') -- all that "A vs. B" stuff that I just don't seem to resonate with any more. Somehow, saintliness in a violence context just doesn't seem as holy to me any more.
"My" saint (Valeria) -- to whom the chant piece I analyzed for my master's degree was dedicated -- was supposedly killed by her fiance, and went to heaven in a ball of flame. Her insistence on converting to Christianity outraged her future husband...there's an awfully fine line between her being honored for her faith (while alive) and for her martyrdom/death. Many traditionally religious people might see no difference. But for me, there is entirely too much violence in this whole construct...Heck, that particular 9th century incident sounds horrifyingly like present-day domestic violence. And the whole "martyr" thing is a hard model for me too, as a modern woman. Even in the 21st century, women too seldom get to live their own lives, aligned solely with their own values and inclinations.
Perhaps, then, this is the last year that these two Christian holy days will resonate at all with me. Any "saintliness" I aspired to as a child certainly never happened within that religious construct (!) From this moment forward, I hope my eyes will see evidence of the Goddess in the world every day; people aligning with Her values for the sheer joy (and logic) of doing so, not as a counterpoint to "evil" or attack, or with the goal of "saving others". It would be lovely to see people regularly manifesting beauty, love and harmony simply because it is the only viable path forward, simply because those are the only qualities they have within them.